Chapter 4

Chapter 4: Collateral Damage

The gala is exactly what I expected: too much money, too little substance, and enough champagne to drown the city's poor. The Architectural Foundation's annual fundraiser always feels like theater—everyone performing their best selves while the actual work of building something meaningful happens in dusty offices and on construction sites.

I'm wearing black because it's easier than pretending I care about fashion. A Vera Wang column dress that costs more than my first car, because Sophie insisted, and because there's something about armor that comes in the form of designer labels. My scar is visible tonight—I've stopped hiding it behind my hair, stopped letting it be the thing I'm ashamed of instead of the thing that proves I survived.

The bergamot and leather of my perfume mingles with the overwhelming floral arrangements that cost more than most people's rent.

"You look like you're attending a funeral," Sophie says, appearing at my elbow with two glasses of champagne and an expression that suggests she's already working the room. She's in crimson, all sharp angles and confidence, her statement earrings catching the light like tiny warnings.

"I am. The death of my will to live."

"Dramatic as always." She hands me a glass. "The Hartley project is here. Three venture capitalists. And—" she lowers her voice conspiratorially, "—that guy from the Times who wrote that piece about your sustainable design philosophy."

I take a sip of champagne that tastes like expensive regret. "The one who called me 'obsessively austere'?"

"That's the one. He's by the bar, and I think he wants to apologize."

"He can want all he likes."

But I'm not really listening to Sophie anymore because my nervous system has just sent out a five-alarm warning. It's not a sound, not exactly. It's a pressure change in the room, like someone's opened a door to somewhere colder.

Marcus Reid has arrived.

I don't look. That's the trick I've learned—if you don't look, maybe the gravitational pull of his presence won't drag you toward him like you're made of iron and he's a magnet wrapped in a bespoke suit. I take another sip of champagne instead, focusing on the bitter bubbles on my tongue, the way the glass is cold against my palm.

He's somewhere to my left. I can feel it the way I can feel a storm coming.

"Oh my God," Sophie breathes, and I know without looking that she's spotted him too. "Is that—?"

"Don't," I say quietly.

"—Marcus Reid? Yes. Yes, it absolutely is. And he's looking at you like—"

"Sophie."

"—like he wants to eat you alive."

I finally turn to look at her, raising an eyebrow. "That's not helpful."

"I'm not trying to be helpful. I'm trying to be honest. You've been sleeping with that man for—"

"I haven't been sleeping with him."

"—and he looks at you like you're the only thing in this room worth looking at. Which, to be fair, you kind of are, but that's not the point. The point is—"

"The point is that I'm going to get another drink, and you're going to stop psychoanalyzing my love life."

"You don't have a love life. You have a project manager with a face that should be illegal."

I'm already moving away, which is the problem. Moving away means moving through the room, and moving through the room means—

"Evelyn."

His voice hits me like a physical thing. Deep and warm and wrapped in cedar and amber and spiced whiskey. I turn, and it's like turning toward a fire—there's danger in it, and heat, and the knowledge that getting too close will burn.

Marcus is in a charcoal suit that fits him like it was painted on, his dark curled hair swept back to reveal the sharp geometry of his face. His gray eyes are doing that thing they do—cataloging, assessing, finding me and holding me like I'm the only equation in the room that matters.

He's with a woman I don't recognize, blonde and polished and clearly important based on the way she's angled toward him. His hand is on her elbow, the gesture courteous and professional, but when he sees me, his fingers tighten almost imperceptibly.

"You're here," he says, and it's such a stupid observation that I almost laugh.

"I'm here. Shocking, I know. It's an architectural gala. Architects tend to attend."

The blonde woman is looking between us with the kind of interest that suggests she's picking up on something. Good. Let her pick up on it. Let everyone pick up on the fact that Marcus Reid is looking at me like he's trying to solve the geometry of my face.

"Let me introduce you," he says, and I watch his jaw tighten as he does, as if introducing me to another woman is physically painful. "This is Catherine Voss, the director of the Metropolitan Arts Initiative. Catherine, this is Evelyn Cross. She's the architect behind the Hartley project."

Catherine extends her hand, and I shake it, noting the firmness of her grip, the intelligence in her eyes. At least she's not an idiot.

"I've heard about your work," Catherine says warmly. "Marcus speaks very highly of you."

I don't look at Marcus. If I look at Marcus, I'll see him confirming this, and if I see him confirming this, I might do something stupid like smile at him, and if I smile at him, I'll lose the careful distance I've been maintaining like it's a life raft in deep water.

"He's biased," I say instead. "It's a professional liability."

"I'm not biased," Marcus says quietly, and there's something in his voice that makes the hair on my arms stand up. "I'm accurate."

Catherine excuses herself with the kind of grace that suggests she's picked up on the electrical charge between us and has decided she doesn't want to be electrocuted. Smart woman.

The moment she's gone, I turn to leave.

"Dance with me," Marcus says.

"No."

"Evelyn."

"I said no, Marcus. I'm not here to—"

"I'm not asking you to do anything. I'm asking you to dance. It's what people do at galas."

The orchestra is playing something classical and mournful. The dance floor is crowded with people in expensive clothes, moving in that careful, controlled way that rich people move, like they're afraid of taking up too much space.

"I don't dance," I say.

"Yes, you do. I've seen you."

He's right. Sophie once dragged me to a club after too many drinks, and there was a moment where I forgot to be afraid, forgot to be careful, and just moved to the music like my body was a language my mind hadn't learned yet. But that was different. That was dark and loud and anonymous.

This is a ballroom full of people who know my name.

"No," I say again, but I'm already considering it, which is the problem. Marcus Reid makes me consider things. Dangerous things. Vulnerable things.

He steps closer, and suddenly the space between us is smaller, the air warmer. His scent wraps around me—cedarwood and amber and that hint of spiced whiskey that makes my hindbrain do something embarrassing.

"One dance," he says. "And then I'll leave you alone for the rest of the night."

"You're lying."

"Absolutely. But you're considering it anyway."

He's right. I am. And the fact that he knows me well enough to know that I'm considering it, that he can read the micro-expressions on my face like I'm a blueprint he's memorized, is both thrilling and terrifying.

I'm about to say no again—I'm very good at saying no—when I see him.

James Holloway.

He's moving through the crowd with that easy grace that made me fall in love with him once, in a different lifetime when I was still someone who believed in happy endings. He's in designer-casual wear—linen shirt, expensive jeans—and he's smiling that smile that convinced me he was the kind of man who would catch me if I fell.

He wasn't.

Marcus sees my face change. I watch him track my gaze, watch his jaw go tight as he identifies the source of my distraction. His hand finds my lower back, and the touch is possessive in a way that makes my pulse stutter.

"Don't," he says quietly.

"Don't what?"

"Whatever you're thinking about doing."

Before I can respond, James has spotted me, and his face lights up with that familiar warmth that once felt like coming home and now just feels like a haunting.

"Evelyn!" He's already moving toward us, and I can feel Marcus's hand on my back like it's a warning or a claim or both. "I didn't know you'd be here. It's been forever."

It's been three years. Exactly three years since he told me he couldn't do this anymore, couldn't be with someone so "damaged," couldn't put his career on hold while I "figured myself out." His words, not mine. Though I've had three years to replay them in my head, to dissect them, to understand that he was just selfish enough to think recovery was something that should happen on his timeline.

"James," I say, and I'm proud of how steady my voice is. "Hi."

He pulls me into a hug, and I let him because it's a public place and making a scene would be worse than tolerating his touch. He smells like citrus and clean linen and vanilla, and I realize with a strange clarity that I don't love him anymore. I don't even like him anymore. He's just a ghost, and ghosts can't hurt you unless you let them.

When he pulls back, his eyes find Marcus, and I watch him do the math. The hand on my back. The proximity. The way Marcus is looking at me like he's two seconds away from dragging me away from this entire situation.

"Marcus Reid," James says, extending his hand. "I've heard about your work. Impressive stuff."

Marcus shakes his hand, and the grip looks like it could crush bone. "I'm sure you have."

The subtext is thick enough to cut. I can feel it vibrating in the space between them—the territorial posturing, the unspoken challenge. It's ridiculous and primitive and somehow deeply arousing, which is a problem because I'm trying very hard not to be attracted to Marcus Reid.

I'm failing.

"So," James says, turning back to me, "I was hoping I could convince you to grab drinks. Catch up. There's so much I want to tell you about what I've been working on."

Behind me, Marcus goes very still. The hand on my back doesn't move, but I can feel the tension in it, the barely restrained energy.

"I don't think that's a good idea," I say.

"Come on," James says, and his smile is so earnest, so convinced that I'm going to say yes, that I almost do. "We're adults. We can have drinks like adults."

It's the confidence that gets me. The absolute certainty that I want this, that I'm going to say yes, that our past is something we can just sip champagne and laugh about. It's so characteristic of him—this inability to understand that he hurt me, that some things can't be fixed with charm and a casual apology.

And maybe that's why I say yes.

"Fine," I hear myself say. "Drinks. Tomorrow. Seven o'clock."

I feel Marcus's hand tighten on my back, feel the sharp intake of breath he tries to hide.

"Perfect," James says, beaming like he's just won something. "I'll text you. Great to see you, Evelyn. Really great."

He drifts back into the crowd, and I'm left standing there with Marcus's hand on my back and the knowledge that I've just made a terrible decision.

"What the fuck was that?" Marcus says quietly.

"That was me saying yes to drinks with an old friend."

"That was you saying yes to drinks with a man who abandoned you while you were recovering from trauma."

I turn to face him, and the movement brings us close enough that I can see the individual threads of gray in his eyes, the tension in his jaw. "That's not your business."

"It is when it affects the project."

"The project." I step away from him, breaking the contact because his hand on my back is making it hard to think. "Right. This is about the project."

"Yes."

"So you don't care that I'm going to have drinks with James. You only care about the project."

His gray eyes are stormy now, dangerous. "Don't put words in my mouth."

"Then what? What do you care about, Marcus?"

"You know what I care about."

We're standing in the middle of a crowded ballroom, and it feels like we're the only two people in the room. Everything else has faded to background noise—the orchestra, the conversations, the gentle clink of glasses. There's just him and me and the space between us that feels like a held breath.

"I don't know anything," I say, and it comes out smaller than I intended. "I know you're brilliant. I know you're intense. I know that you smell like cedarwood and make me want to do stupid things. But I don't know what you care about."

His hand comes up, and for a moment I think he's going to touch my face, trace the line of my scar with his thumb the way he did in his office. But he doesn't. He drops his hand.

"I care about you not getting hurt," he says quietly. "Which is apparently my problem, not yours."

"That's not fair."

"No," he agrees. "It's not. But it's true. And you can go have drinks with James Holloway if you want. You can go home with him. You can do whatever you want. But I'm not going to stand here and pretend I'm fine with it."

"You don't get to not be fine with it. You don't own me."

"I know that. Do you?"

The words hit like a slap. Because the question isn't about ownership—it's about control. It's about whether I'm making this choice because I want to, or because some part of me is still broken enough to seek out the ghosts that haunt me.

"I'm going to the bar," I say coldly. "And then I'm going home. Alone. And tomorrow I'm going to have drinks with James because I'm an adult who can make her own decisions, even if they're bad ones."

"Evelyn—"

"Don't," I say, and I'm surprised by how much it costs me to walk away from him. Every step feels like a betrayal of something I don't fully understand yet.

I make it to the bar and order a whiskey, neat. The bartender doesn't ask questions—I'm clearly the kind of woman who drinks whiskey neat at galas and doesn't care what people think about it.

Sophie finds me ten minutes later, and she takes one look at my face and knows.

"What happened?"

"Nothing. Everything. I'm going home."

"But the Hartley people—"

"I'm going home, Sophie."

I'm already moving toward the exit, already pulling out my phone to call a car. Behind me, I can feel Marcus watching me leave. I don't turn around. If I turn around, I might see something in his face that makes me want to stay, and I've already made enough bad decisions tonight.

The car arrives, and I slide into the back seat and give the driver my address. As we pull away from the curb, I catch a glimpse of the gala in the rearview mirror—the lights, the people, the ballroom full of important conversations that suddenly feel very small.

My phone buzzes.

Don't do this.

Just that. No signature, but I know it's Marcus. I don't respond. Instead, I turn my phone off and watch the city blur past the window, my reflection staring back at me like a stranger.

The scar on my face catches the streetlight, and I trace it with my finger, remembering the moment I decided to stop hiding it. Remembering that strength isn't about being untouchable.

It's about letting people see that you've been touched and survived it anyway.

By the time I get home, I'm shaking.

I pour myself a drink—the good whiskey, the kind Marcus brought to my apartment once—and I sit in the dark and I think about James, about Marcus, about the difference between a man who runs when things get hard and a man who stays even when you push him away.

The problem is that staying can be just as dangerous as running.

And tomorrow, I'm going to have drinks with a ghost and prove to myself that I'm brave enough to face my past.

Even if it's the stupidest thing I've ever done.

My phone, powered back on, immediately fills with notifications. Texts from Sophie. Missed calls from Marcus. A voicemail I'm almost afraid to listen to.

I delete them all.

Then I open my messages and text James: Tomorrow. Seven. The Meridian Bar.

The response comes immediately: Can't wait to see you.

I set my phone down and finish my drink in the dark, wondering if I'm being brave or just self-destructive, and unable to tell the difference anymore.

You might like