I've become excellent at cancellations.
The first one is easy. A work crisis—completely fabricated, but believable because I'm Evelyn Chen and I'm always working on something. I send the message to Marcus at 6:47 PM on a Tuesday, right before our scheduled tutoring session, giving him just enough notice to rearrange but not enough time to argue.
Emergency client call. Have to reschedule. Sorry.
Three words. Professional. Clean. The kind of message that doesn't invite follow-up questions.
He responds within minutes: No problem. Thursday instead?
I don't answer until Wednesday afternoon.
The second cancellation requires slightly more creativity. I claim a migraine, which is technically honest because I do get migraines when I'm stressed, and I am definitely stressed. Just not in the way he'd think. The stress comes from the way my apartment feels too quiet when he's not here. From the fact that I caught myself looking at his messages three times in an hour. From the absolutely unacceptable realization that I've started timing my runs to pass by his office building.
This is pathological. This is exactly the kind of dependent behavior I've spent my entire adult life avoiding.
Feel better soon, he writes, and there's something in that message—something in the simplicity of it—that makes my chest tight in a way I refuse to examine.
The third cancellation is the hardest because I'm running out of excuses and because Marcus is running out of patience. Not with me, which is somehow worse. He's patient in a way that makes me want to scream. Patient in a way that suggests he'll wait forever, and the thought of someone waiting forever for me is terrifying in ways I can't articulate.
Swamped with the Hartley account, I write. Probably won't have time for tutoring for a few weeks. Sorry to leave you hanging.
I hit send and immediately silence my phone notifications.
The lie tastes like ash.
For approximately forty-eight hours, I convince myself this is the right choice. Distance equals safety. Separation equals survival. I've built my entire life on this principle, and it's worked beautifully—I'm successful, independent, untouchable. The fact that I'm also fundamentally alone is simply the price of not being destroyed again.
My father, however, has other ideas.
"Lunch," he says when he calls on Friday morning, his voice carrying that particular tone that suggests this isn't a request. "Tomorrow. That little place you like on Fifth."
"Dad, I'm really busy—"
"Evelyn." One word. My name. A gentle hammer.
I go to lunch.
The restaurant is exactly as I remember: small, intimate, with excellent Vietnamese pho and the kind of quiet that comes from being tucked away on a side street. My father is already there when I arrive, sitting at our usual table by the window, two waters already poured. He looks older than he did the last time I saw him, which was only three weeks ago. The guilt settles heavy in my stomach.
"You look tired," he says, which is code for you look like you're self-destructing.
"Work's been intense," I say, which is code for I'm not talking about this.
He lets me have that lie for exactly as long as it takes to order. Then, while we're waiting for the food, he sets down his chopsticks and looks at me with those warm brown eyes that have always been able to see straight through my bullshit.
"You're running again," he says quietly.
"I'm not—"
"Evelyn."
I close my mouth.
He reaches across the table, and I have to actively restrain myself from pulling away when his hand covers mine. His skin is warm, papery with age, and the gesture is so achingly gentle that I feel something crack in my chest.
"I need to tell you something," he continues, "and I need you to listen without arguing. Can you do that?"
I nod, because refusing would require explaining why I can't, and I'm not ready to go there.
"When you were being bullied in high school," he says, "your mother and I knew. We knew it was happening, and we tried to help. We called the school, we talked to you, we did everything we thought was right. But we didn't fight hard enough. We didn't make enough noise. We let the system convince us that you needed to handle it, that you needed to be strong enough to survive it on your own."
His voice cracks slightly.
"I've spent the last fifteen years regretting that. Regretting that I didn't burn down that entire institution to protect you. And I've watched you build a life where you don't need anyone, where you're so independent that you're lonely, and I..." He pauses, swallows. "I made a choice to accept that, because I thought it was what you needed. But I was wrong."
"Dad—"
"Let me finish." His grip on my hand tightens slightly. "I see what's happening with Marcus. I see how you light up when you talk about his business strategy, and I see how you've suddenly decided that's too dangerous. And I'm telling you, as someone who has already lived with the regret of choosing safety over connection, please don't do this. Please don't spend your life running from the possibility of being happy because you're terrified of being hurt."
The food arrives, and we both pretend we're not sitting here with our eyes burning.
I push my pho around with my chopsticks, watching the noodles swirl through the broth like they're drowning. Maybe they are. Maybe we're all drowning and just pretending the water is fine.
"It's not that simple," I finally say.
"No," my father agrees. "It's not. But it's also not as complicated as you're making it. He's not the same person he was in high school."
"People don't change."
"Some do." He picks up his chopsticks again, takes a bite like he hasn't just detonated my entire worldview. "Not easily. Not without work. But some do."
I don't respond because I can't, because if I acknowledge that Marcus might have genuinely changed, then I have to acknowledge that my fear isn't actually about protecting myself from his cruelty. It's about protecting myself from the vulnerability of wanting something—wanting someone—and having no guarantee that it won't be used against me.
It's about control.
And if there's one thing I've learned about myself, it's that I'll sacrifice almost anything to maintain it.
We finish lunch in relative silence. My father pays, kisses my forehead, and tells me he loves me. I tell him I love him too, and I mean it with an intensity that makes me angry because it proves his point. I'm capable of love. I'm just terrified of it.
The next three days are a masterclass in self-torture.
I throw myself into work with the kind of manic energy that usually precedes a breakdown. I review contracts until my eyes blur. I take calls at midnight. I reorganize my entire filing system because apparently that's what functional adults do when they're avoiding thinking about a man who smells like cedar and leather and looks at them like they're worth burning the world for.
By Wednesday, I'm running on coffee and spite.
The email arrives at 3:17 PM, and it's from a forwarded address I don't immediately recognize. But the subject line makes my stomach drop:
Re: Whitmore Industries Strategic Expansion—Project Status Update
I open it with trembling hands.
The message is from Marcus's business partner, Daniel. It's professional, concise, and devastating:
Marcus—The revised market analysis we discussed is missing key components. The projections aren't holding up without the restructured financial models we were working on. We're going to need to either find someone else to finish this or push the timeline back by six weeks. Let me know how you want to proceed.
It's been forwarded to me with a single line from Marcus:
Thought you should know.
I read it four times, trying to find the accusation in those words. Trying to find the manipulation, the guilt-trip, the attempt to pull me back in. But there isn't one. It's just a fact, delivered with the kind of quiet resignation that suggests he's already accepted the loss.
My hands are shaking.
The rational part of my brain—the part that's kept me alive and functional all these years—is screaming that this is exactly what I wanted. Distance. Separation. A clean break from something that was becoming too important, too consuming, too dangerous.
But the rest of me, the part that's been slowly starving since I canceled that first session, is recognizing this for what it actually is: a consequence.
I've been so focused on protecting myself that I didn't stop to consider what I was protecting myself from. And the answer is becoming increasingly clear: I was protecting myself from the possibility that someone could matter to me. That I could matter to someone.
That I could want something and not be destroyed by wanting it.
I close the email and stare at my blank computer screen.
The problem with Marcus isn't that he's cruel or dangerous or unworthy of trust. The problem with Marcus is that he's exactly the kind of person who could make me believe in things like redemption and second chances and the possibility of being loved by someone who knows exactly who you are and chooses you anyway.
The problem with Marcus is that he's making it increasingly difficult to believe my own lies.
My phone buzzes. A text from an unknown number, but I know exactly who it is because I've memorized the pattern of his messages—the careful spacing, the lack of emojis, the way he never uses exclamation points even when he's excited.
Your father and I are having dinner tomorrow. He mentioned you might want to join us.
I stare at the message.
That's not an accident. My father wouldn't have mentioned anything to Marcus unless Marcus had asked. And Marcus wouldn't have asked unless he was looking for a way to see me that didn't involve asking directly, which means he's been thinking about me, which means the distance I created hasn't actually solved anything because he's still there, still present, still waiting.
I could ignore this. I could delete it, block the number, disappear into my work and my carefully constructed isolation and pretend that this entire chapter of my life was a mistake.
I could.
But my father's words are still echoing in my head: Please don't spend your life running from the possibility of being happy because you're terrified of being hurt.
I type out a response: What time?
Send it before I can overthink it.
The response comes back immediately: 7 PM. Your father's favorite place. I'll pick you up at 6:30.
Just like that, I've agreed to spend an evening in close proximity to Marcus Whitmore while my father watches like he's attending the world's most important romantic comedy.
I put my head down on my desk and seriously consider the logistics of faking my own death.
The thing about running is that it only works if you're faster than whatever's chasing you.
And I'm starting to suspect that what's chasing me isn't Marcus at all. It's the version of myself that I've been running from since high school—the girl who wanted things, who needed things, who believed that love was something that could happen to her despite all evidence to the contrary.
The girl who's still starving.
By 6:15 PM the next evening, I've changed outfits four times and convinced myself that this is a terrible idea exactly seven times. I've also applied and reapplied makeup because apparently I'm seventeen again and completely irrational.
When the car pulls up outside my apartment building, I'm standing at the window in my third outfit—black pants, a cream silk blouse that probably costs more than my monthly coffee budget, and a leather jacket that's supposed to make me look like someone who has her shit together.
I do not have my shit together.
Marcus is wearing a charcoal suit and that cologne, and when I slide into the passenger seat, the scent of it hits me like a physical blow. Cedar and leather and something underneath that's just him, something my body recognizes on a cellular level and responds to with absolutely no regard for my carefully constructed emotional boundaries.
"Hi," he says, and his voice is careful. Like I'm something fragile that might break.
"Hi," I reply, and I'm acutely aware of every inch of space between us. Approximately two feet. Could be miles. Could be nothing.
The drive to the restaurant is quiet except for the low murmur of the radio. I can feel him wanting to say something, the silence stretching taut between us like a string pulled too tight. But he doesn't push, and somehow that's worse because it means he's learned me. He knows that pushing will make me run faster.
My father is already at the table when we arrive, and the look on his face when he sees us together is something between triumph and profound relief. I want to kick him. I also want to hug him, which means I do neither and instead sit down very carefully and focus on the menu like it contains the secrets of the universe.
"Marcus was just telling me about the expansion project," my father says, completely oblivious to the fact that I'm currently a live wire of anxiety and conflicting emotions. "Sounds like you were instrumental in the initial framework."
"Was," Marcus says, and there's a weight in that word that makes me look up. He's watching me across the table, and his expression is unreadable. "The project stalled without the financial restructuring Evelyn designed."
My father looks between us like he's watching a tennis match.
"It's not that complicated," I hear myself say. "You could hire someone else to finish it."
"I could," Marcus agrees. "But it wouldn't be the same. You understood what I was trying to do. You understood the vision in a way that most people don't."
The way he's looking at me makes it very difficult to breathe.
"That's not true," I say, but my voice sounds weak even to my own ears.
"It is." He leans forward slightly. "You see things that other people miss. You ask questions that make me think differently. You make me better."
This is not the conversation I prepared for. This is not the casual, friendly dinner I thought I was attending. This is a man laying himself out, and I'm acutely aware that my father is watching this with the intensity of someone who's been waiting for this moment.
"I should go to the restroom," my father announces suddenly, standing up. "Evelyn, come with me?"
I want to refuse, but he's already moving, and there's a look in his eyes that suggests this isn't optional.
In the bathroom, he pulls me into a hug before I can protest.
"He's waiting for you," my father says softly. "He's been waiting since you started avoiding him. And I think you've been waiting too, just too scared to admit it."
"Dad—"
"No." He pulls back, holds my shoulders. "I'm not going to force you to do anything. But I am going to tell you that sometimes the scariest thing is also the most necessary thing. And sometimes the people who hurt us aren't the same people they were before."
He kisses my forehead and leaves me standing there in a restaurant bathroom, staring at my reflection in the mirror.
The girl looking back at me looks terrified.
When I return to the table, Marcus is exactly where I left him, but something in his posture has changed. He looks tired. Like he's been carrying something heavy for a long time.
"I've been thinking about what you said," he tells me quietly, "about how people don't change. And I get it. I do. You have every reason not to trust me, not to believe that I'm anything other than the asshole I was in high school. But I need you to know that I'm not asking you to forgive me for your sake. I'm asking you to consider it for yours."
I can feel my heart rate accelerating.
"Because watching you hide," he continues, "watching you pretend that you don't want this, that you don't want us, is killing me. And I know I don't have the right to ask you to take a chance on me. But I'm asking anyway."
The restaurant around us seems to disappear.
"This is insane," I whisper.
"Completely," he agrees. "But you're brilliant, Evelyn, and you're beautiful, and you're the most fascinating person I've ever met. And I would very much like the opportunity to prove to you that I'm not going to destroy you."
"You might," I say, and it's the most honest thing I've said to him. "You might hurt me anyway, even if you don't mean to."
"I might," he acknowledges. "But you might also be the best thing that ever happened to me. And I'm willing to take that risk if you are."
He reaches across the table, his hand palm-up, an offering.
I look at his hand for what feels like an eternity. I think about safety and control and the comfortable prison I've built for myself. I think about my father's regret and my own profound loneliness. I think about the way my body responds to his proximity, the way my mind lights up when we work through problems together, the way he looks at me like I'm worth something.
I think about the cost of never trying.
Very slowly, I reach across the table and place my hand in his.
His fingers close around mine, warm and solid, and I can feel his pulse racing under his skin. Or maybe that's my pulse. Maybe we're both terrified.
"Okay," I say quietly.
"Okay?"
"Okay, I'll... I'll try. But if you hurt me—"
"I won't." His grip tightens slightly. "I won't."
My father returns to the table at that exact moment, sees our joined hands, and very deliberately does not smile. But I can see it in his eyes, and I want to kill him for being right.
For the rest of dinner, I'm acutely aware of Marcus's hand on my knee under the table. It's barely touching me, just enough pressure to remind me that he's there, that this is real, that I've somehow agreed to the most terrifying thing I could possibly agree to.
When he drives me home, he walks me to my door.
"I don't expect anything," he says quietly. "I just want a chance."
I nod, not trusting my voice.
He reaches out and tucks a strand of hair behind my ear, his fingers lingering against my cheek for just a moment. The touch is gentle, reverent, and it makes me feel like something precious.
"Goodnight, Evelyn," he says.
I watch him walk back to his car, and I realize with startling clarity that I'm not running anymore.
The question is whether I'm brave enough to actually stay.








