Chapter 6

Chapter 6: The Confrontation

The knock comes at 9:47 PM on a Thursday, which is precisely the kind of unannounced visit that makes my stomach drop into my shoes.

I know it's him before I even look through the peephole. Some part of me has been waiting for this moment since I saw him at the gala, since I felt his eyes on me like hands I wasn't supposed to want touching me. The universe doesn't let you keep secrets this big. The universe is a petty bitch with a sense of irony.

I check on Lily first—she's asleep, her small form burrowed under the duvet, one hand clutching the stuffed rabbit she's had since she was two. The sight of her steadies me the way nothing else can. This is why. Whatever comes next, whatever he says, whatever he demands—it was worth it to keep her safe.

When I open the door, Sebastian is standing in my hallway in a bespoke suit that probably costs more than my rent, his jaw clenched so tight I can see the muscle working beneath his skin. His slate-gray eyes are a storm.

"We need to talk," he says, and his voice is so controlled it's terrifying. Controlled anger is always worse than the explosive kind.

"It's late. Lily's asleep."

"I don't care."

He steps inside without waiting for an invitation, and I'm forced to close the door behind him or let my neighbors enjoy the show. The hallway suddenly feels very small with him in it. He's brought that scent with him—cedar and smoke and something darker, leather and aged whiskey—and it fills my lungs in a way that makes me furious at my own body for responding.

"You need to leave," I say, but we both know I don't mean it.

He pulls something from his jacket pocket. Photographs. Several of them, printed on expensive photo paper, and my blood goes cold because I know exactly what they show before I even look.

Lily at the coffee shop last week, her sharp gray eyes visible in profile.

Lily at her soccer practice, her auburn hair catching the afternoon light.

Lily and me together, the resemblance unmistakable to anyone who knows how to look.

"Jesus Christ, Evelyn." His voice cracks on my name, and that crack does more damage than any shout could have. "How long were you planning to keep this from me?"

I take the photographs from his hands because touching them feels like I'm supposed to, like this is some kind of ritual I need to complete. My fingers are steady. Everything else in me is chaos.

"We should talk in the living room," I say quietly.

"I don't want to sit down. I want you to tell me that these aren't what I think they are."

He's standing too close. That's deliberate on his part—an invasion of space meant to make me uncomfortable, to push me off balance. It works. I can feel the heat radiating from him, can smell that intoxicating scent that's become as dangerous to me as a drug, and it's making it hard to think clearly.

I step back.

"Her name is Lily," I say. "She's seven years old. She likes building things and asking questions that make adults uncomfortable. She has your eyes."

The photographs slip from my hands and scatter across the hardwood floor like fallen leaves.

Sebastian doesn't look at them. He's looking at me, and there's something in his expression that makes my chest constrict painfully—a mixture of devastation and rage that I caused. I did this. I made this happen.

"Seven years," he says quietly. "You've had her for seven years and didn't think I had a right to know?"

"That's not—" I start, but he cuts me off with a sharp gesture.

"Don't. Don't you dare try to explain this away. She's my daughter. My daughter, Evelyn, and you kept her from me like I'm some kind of threat."

The accusation lands because it's partially true, and we both know it.

"You were different then," I say, and my voice is shaking now despite my best efforts to keep it level. "You were ruthless. You were building an empire. You didn't have time for—"

"For what? A child? For her?" He runs a hand through his hair, and I can see his hands are shaking now too. "You don't get to make that decision for me. You don't get to decide what I can handle or what I deserve to know about my own child."

"I was protecting her."

"From what? From me?"

The question hangs in the air between us, and I can't answer it because the answer is complicated and messy and rooted in my own trauma. Yes. No. Maybe. All of the above.

"You didn't want this," I say instead, and my voice is so quiet it's almost a whisper. "You made that clear. You were focused on work, on building your empire. You told me yourself that you didn't have time for complications."

"I never said—" He stops, and I watch understanding dawn on his face. "When? When did I say that?"

I don't answer.

"Evelyn. When?"

"Right before I found out I was pregnant," I admit. "You were closing the Meridian deal. You told me you couldn't be distracted, that you needed to focus on work for the next year. That you couldn't afford to have someone depending on you."

He looks like I've physically struck him.

"So you just... left? Without telling me? Without giving me a chance to—" He stops, unable to finish the sentence. "Do you understand what you took from me?"

The pain in his voice is worse than anger ever could be. It's raw and real and completely justified, and I hate myself for being the cause of it.

"I was scared," I say, and the admission costs me something. Vulnerability is a liability. Needing people is how you get abandoned. I learned that lesson early and learned it well. "I was terrified. I'd just gotten my business off the ground. I didn't have money or stability or anything to offer a child. And you—"

"I would have been there."

"You didn't want to be."

"You don't know that. You assumed it. You decided what was best for everyone without asking anyone involved." He turns away from me, and I watch his shoulders rise and fall as he tries to breathe through the rage. "She's mine. She's my daughter, and I've missed seven years of her life because you decided I didn't deserve to know about her."

The accusation is fair, and that's what makes it hurt.

"I did what I thought was right," I say, and I hate how defensive I sound. "I built a life for her. I kept her safe. I made sure she had stability and a parent who was present, who wasn't going to abandon her or—"

"Or what? Repeat your mother's mistakes?" His voice is sharp, clinical. "Is that what this is about? You're so terrified of being abandoned that you decided to do the abandoning first?"

It's such a direct hit that I flinch visibly.

"You don't get to use my trauma against me."

"I'm not using anything. I'm stating a fact. You made a decision based on your own fear, and you kept me from my daughter because of it."

I want to argue with him. I want to defend myself, to explain that I was twenty-five years old and alone and terrified, that I made the best decision I could with the information I had, that I was trying to protect her from the chaos of his world. But the words stick in my throat because he's right.

I did decide for him.

I did let my own abandonment issues drive a choice that wasn't mine to make alone.

And I've been lying to him—and to Lily—for seven years.

"What do you want?" I ask quietly. "Why are you here?"

"I want to know everything. I want to know why you left. I want to know why you didn't come back. I want to know why you thought you had the right to keep her from me."

"And then what? You take her? You decide you want to be a father now that she's convenient?"

The words are cruel, and I know they are, but I'm lashing out because I'm scared. I'm terrified of losing her. I'm terrified of what his world could do to her. I'm terrified of how much I want him to stay and how much I need him to leave.

His expression hardens.

"That's not fair."

"Fair?" I laugh, and it's a bitter sound. "You want to talk about fair? It's not fair that I had to make this decision alone. It's not fair that I had to choose between my career and my child. It's not fair that I had to leave the only person I've ever—" I stop myself before I can finish that sentence, but it's too late. The words are already hanging in the air between us.

The only person I've ever loved.

He hears it anyway. I can see it in the way his expression shifts, in the way his hands clench into fists at his sides.

"You should have told me," he says quietly. "Whatever else happened, whatever reasons you had—you should have told me."

"I know."

"I deserve to know my daughter. She deserves to know me."

"I know," I repeat, and the acceptance in my voice seems to deflate some of his anger, replacing it with something worse—grief.

"I want to meet her," he says. "Properly. I want to know her."

"She's asleep. It's nearly ten o'clock."

"Then tomorrow. I want to meet her tomorrow."

The thought of it makes my chest tighten. Once he meets her, once she knows who he is, everything changes. The careful world I've built for her, the controlled environment where it's just the two of us against the world—it shatters.

"She doesn't know," I say. "She doesn't know who you are."

Something flickers across his face—hurt, maybe, or resignation. "Then I suppose we have a lot to talk about."

He moves toward the door, and I realize with a start that he's leaving. Part of me—the selfish, terrified part—is relieved. But another part of me, the part that's been waiting seven years for this, wants to reach out and stop him.

"Sebastian—" I start, but he's already opening the door.

He pauses in the threshold, and for a moment, I think he might turn around. I think he might come back, might pull me close, might tell me that we can figure this out together.

Instead, he says, "I need time to process this. I need to figure out how to explain to a seven-year-old that her mother lied to her entire life about who her father is." His voice is hollow, emptied of everything but pain. "I'll be back tomorrow at noon. Be ready to introduce me."

And then he's gone, and I'm standing alone in my hallway with scattered photographs at my feet and the lingering scent of cedar and smoke and everything I've been running from.

I sink onto the bottom step of the stairs and let myself fall apart, just for a moment, just long enough to feel the weight of what I've done.

Then I pull myself together, because Lily might wake up, and she can't see me like this.

Tomorrow, everything changes.

Tomorrow, I lose the only thing I've ever been able to control.

Tomorrow, I have to tell my daughter the truth about her father, and I have absolutely no idea how to do it without breaking both of us in the process.

You might like