Chapter 4

Chapter 4: The Child Question

The restaurant is exactly the kind of place I normally avoid—all exposed brick and Edison bulbs and waiters who describe the food like they're selling religion. Which means Sebastian chose it specifically to make me uncomfortable. It's the sort of tactical move I respect in business and despise in dating, which is a problem because this isn't dating. This is due diligence. A working dinner. A perfectly reasonable continuation of our professional relationship.

I'm lying to myself again. I've gotten very good at it.

"You're tense," Sebastian observes, not looking up from his wine. He has the kind of confidence that doesn't require eye contact to make a point. "I can feel it from here. Your shoulders are practically up around your ears."

"I'm focused," I correct, stabbing at my sea bass with more force than necessary. "There's a difference."

"Not in your case." Now he does look at me, and it's the kind of look that makes my skin feel too small. Slate-gray eyes that catalog and calculate. "You go tense when you're trying not to want something. I've noticed."

The fork pauses halfway to my mouth. "That's a remarkably presumptuous observation."

"I'm a remarkably presumptuous man." He says it without arrogance, which somehow makes it worse. "It's served me well in business. People underestimate how much you can learn by actually paying attention."

I set the fork down because my hands are starting to shake, which is unacceptable. "What exactly are you paying attention to, Sebastian?"

"Everything." He leans back slightly, giving me space I didn't ask for but apparently need. "The way you check your phone every ninety seconds. The way your eyes go soft when you look at whatever you're checking. The way you become a completely different person for approximately five seconds before you remember you're supposed to be invulnerable."

My stomach drops.

I reach for my wine with deliberate calm, but my phone is sitting on the table between us like a small bomb with a faulty timer. I haven't looked at it in—I glance at my watch—four minutes. That's a new record. Usually I'm checking for updates from the nanny every three minutes like Lily might spontaneously combust without my supervision.

"I'm a busy woman," I say carefully. "I have a lot of moving parts."

"You do." He's still watching me with that unsettling intensity. "But that's not what the phone is about, is it?"

The waiter chooses this moment to materialize with fresh bread and an obsequious smile. I've never been more grateful for an interruption in my life. I use the thirty seconds of distraction to school my features back into professional composure, to build the walls higher, thicker, impenetrable.

It doesn't work.

Sebastian waits until the waiter is gone, then reaches across the table with unhurried grace. His fingers brush my phone, not picking it up, just touching the edge of it like he's testing whether I'll stop him.

I don't.

"May I?" he asks, and it's not really a question because his hand is already moving.

"No," I say, but it's too late. He's already swiped to my lock screen, and there she is.

Lily, mid-laugh, head thrown back, her hair catching the afternoon light like copper wire. She's wearing the dinosaur shirt she insisted on despite it being three sizes too big, and she's holding a stick she'd decided was a "magic wand for building things." The photo is from last weekend—I remember the exact moment I took it because I'd been thinking about how I'd never seen her that purely happy, that unselfconsciously joyful.

Now a stranger is looking at my daughter.

I reach across the table and take the phone back, but it's too late for that too. The damage is done. I can see it in the way his entire body goes still, the way his eyes track the photo as I pull it away, the way something shifts in his expression—not surprise, exactly, but a recalibration. A reconsideration.

"Who is that?" he asks quietly.

My heart is doing something violent against my ribs. "That's none of your business."

"She has your eyes," he continues, ignoring my deflection. "And your hair. And something about the smile that's—" He stops, watching my face like he's reading a particularly complex contract. "Who is she?"

I could lie. I'm good at lying. I've had seven years to perfect the art of constructing narratives that protect what matters most. But there's something in the way he's looking at me—not predatory, not yet—that makes me think a lie might be worse than the truth.

"My daughter," I say, and the words feel like stepping off a cliff.

The silence that follows is the kind that has weight.

"You have a daughter." He says it slowly, like he's testing how the words fit. "How old?"

"Seven."

"And her father?"

"Not in the picture." It's technically true. It's also a masterpiece of omission.

Sebastian leans back in his chair, and I watch him process this information like he's running calculations in his head. The candlelight catches the sharp line of his jaw, the slight tension in his throat. He's thinking very hard about something, and I can practically see the gears turning behind those gray eyes.

"You never mentioned her," he says finally.

"I don't mention most things about my personal life. That's not relevant to our business relationship."

"Isn't it?" He picks up his wine again, a deliberate gesture that somehow feels more confrontational than if he'd leaned forward. "I think it's extremely relevant. I think it explains quite a lot, actually."

I don't ask what he means. I'm afraid I already know.

"She's adopted," I hear myself say, and I hate myself immediately for the lie, for the way it tastes like copper and cowardice. "Private arrangement. It's all very legal and above board."

Sebastian doesn't respond immediately. He just watches me over the rim of his glass, and I can see the exact moment he decides not to believe me. It's in the slight tightening around his eyes, the almost imperceptible shift in his posture.

"That's interesting," he says mildly. "Because you have that particular look that people get when they're protecting something precious. And it's not the look of someone who adopted a child through standard channels. That look is—" He pauses, searching for the word. "Territorial. Desperate. Like you'd burn the world down rather than lose her."

"I would," I say, and I don't bother lying about that part. "Regardless of how she came to be mine."

"I'm not asking you to explain yourself." He sets down his glass with precise care. "I'm just noting that there's a story there. A story you're not telling me."

"Some stories aren't mine to tell."

"And some stories involve me." He says it quietly, but there's an edge underneath that makes my pulse stutter. "Don't they?"

The room suddenly feels very small. The air is too warm, too thick with his cologne—that expensive bergamot and cedar smoke that I've started smelling in my own apartment even when he's not there. I've started craving it in a way that terrifies me.

"I don't know what you're implying," I say carefully.

"I'm implying nothing." He reaches for his water glass, and his hand brushes mine across the table. It's barely a touch, but it's enough to make my entire nervous system light up like a Christmas tree. "I'm stating a fact. You have a seven-year-old daughter. You're thirty-two. That means she was born when you were twenty-five. And I'm trying to remember where you were seven years ago."

"Somewhere you weren't," I say, pulling my hand back like his skin is radioactive.

"Exactly." He smiles, and it's not a nice smile. It's the smile of a man who's just solved a puzzle he didn't know he was working on. "Exactly where I wasn't. Which is interesting, because I was fairly certain I knew where you were seven years ago."

I stand up, my napkin falling to the floor like I've abandoned all pretense of civility. "This conversation is over."

"Sit down, Evelyn."

"No."

"Please." The word changes everything. It's not a command, not a threat. It's a request, and somehow that's worse. "Sit down. Let me finish."

I sit, because apparently I have no self-preservation instinct whatsoever.

"I'm not going to ask you to confirm or deny anything," he continues, his voice low enough that the other diners can't hear. "I'm not even going to ask you why you disappeared for six months seven years ago without telling anyone where you were going. Yet."

"How do you know I—"

"Because I remember you," he interrupts. "I remember you very well. And then suddenly you were gone, and when you came back, you were different. Harder. More careful. And you had a daughter."

I can't breathe properly. My chest is too tight, my vision is starting to tunnel at the edges. This is what happens when you build your entire life on a foundation of lies—eventually, someone with enough resources and enough obsession starts pulling at the threads.

"Even if what you're implying were true—which it's not—it wouldn't change anything," I say, and I'm proud of how steady my voice sounds. "It would be ancient history. Water under the bridge. A moment of weakness that resulted in a human being I love more than my own life. And I will burn you to the ground before I let you use her as leverage."

"I don't want to use her as leverage." He says it like I've insulted him. "I want to understand why you're so terrified of me knowing the truth."

"Because the truth is dangerous." I lean forward, and now I'm the one invading his space, and he doesn't move away. "The truth is that you're a man who likes to own things. You like to possess them and control them and make them part of your empire. And I will not—I will never—let you do that to her."

"To her." He catches on the phrasing immediately. "Not to the situation. Not to the circumstances. To her specifically."

I realize my mistake too late.

"I'm not going to confirm anything," I say coldly, gathering my things. "This dinner is over. We're done."

I stand, and this time I don't sit back down.

Sebastian lets me leave, which is somehow worse than if he'd tried to stop me. As I walk toward the exit, I can feel his eyes on my back, burning like a brand. And I know—with the kind of certainty that makes my stomach churn—that he's not going to let this go.

Men like Sebastian Ashford don't let mysteries go.

They solve them.

---

I call Margot the moment I get in the car, my hands shaking so badly I have to use the hands-free system.

"Tell me you're calling to say you're finally fucking him," she answers, because she has no concept of professional phone etiquette.

"He knows," I say, and my voice sounds very far away. "Not everything, but he knows something. He's going to dig, Margot. He's going to find—"

"Slow down." Her tone shifts immediately from teasing to tactical. "What exactly does he know?"

"That Lily exists. That she's mine. That the timeline doesn't add up for a standard adoption."

There's a pause while Margot processes this. I can hear her thinking, which is both comforting and terrifying because Margot is the only person who knows the full story, and if she's worried, I should be very worried.

"Okay," she says finally. "Okay, that's not as bad as it could be. He doesn't know for certain—"

"He will. He's Sebastian Ashford. He has security teams and lawyers and apparently an excellent memory. He's going to connect the dots, and when he does—"

"When he does, you decide what you want to tell him," Margot says firmly. "You don't panic. You don't run. You make a choice from a position of strength, not fear."

"There is no position of strength here. If he knows, if he decides he wants—Margot, he could take her. Legally, he could—"

"He's not going to take her."

"You don't know that."

"No," Margot agrees. "But I know him. Or I know enough about him to know that he's not the type to rip a child away from her mother. That's not his style. His style is to want to build something, not destroy it."

"His style is to own things."

"Yes. And if he figures out that she's his, he's not going to want to own her like a possession. He's going to want to own her like a legacy."

The distinction doesn't comfort me nearly as much as Margot probably intended it to.

I drive home in silence, my mind spinning through worst-case scenarios like a particularly cruel slideshow. Sebastian with lawyers. Sebastian with DNA tests. Sebastian with a court order and a desire to be part of Lily's life that I can't control or prevent.

Sebastian knowing that she's his and deciding that he has a right to her.

The nanny has already put Lily to bed by the time I get home. I check on her anyway, standing in her doorway and watching her sleep. She's sprawled across her bed like she owns it, one arm flung over her stuffed octopus, her chest rising and falling with the kind of peaceful breathing that only children seem to manage.

She has his eyes. She's always had his eyes, and I've spent seven years trying not to see it, trying not to think about the man they came from, trying not to remember the exact circumstances of her creation.

I fail at all three constantly.

I close her door quietly and go to my own room, where I spend the next four hours staring at my ceiling and contemplating the various ways my life can implode.

By morning, I've made a decision.

I need to get ahead of this.

---

My phone rings at 8 a.m. while I'm making Lily's lunch. It's a blocked number, which means it's probably not good news.

I answer anyway.

"Ms. Harper?" A woman's voice, professional and clipped. "This is Jennifer Park from Ashford Security. Mr. Ashford would like to schedule a meeting with you. Today, if possible."

Of course he would.

"Tell Mr. Ashford that I'm busy," I say, which is both true and a lie. I'm not busy. I'm terrified. But I'm not going to admit that to a security contractor.

"He anticipated you might say that." There's a pause, and I can hear the sound of papers shuffling. "He also asked me to inform you that this meeting is non-negotiable. And that it concerns a matter of significant personal importance."

"If this is about last night—"

"It's not about last night," Jennifer Park interrupts. "Though Mr. Ashford did ask me to inform you that he's reconsidered his position on several things, and he'd like to discuss them with you in person. He suggests the office. Neutral territory."

Neutral territory. As if there's any such thing when Sebastian Ashford is involved.

"Fine," I say. "Three o'clock. My office."

"Actually, Mr. Ashford prefers his office. He'll send a car at 2:45."

The line goes dead.

I stand in my kitchen with Lily's half-made sandwich in my hands and try very hard not to panic. This is a negotiation. This is a business meeting. This is me controlling the narrative instead of letting it control me.

I'm lying again.

By 2:30, I've changed outfits four times and applied makeup with the precision of someone preparing for battle. I've also texted Margot approximately seventeen times, each message more panicked than the last. She's told me to "woman up" and "stop being a coward" and "just tell him the fucking truth," which is easy for her to say because it's not her daughter's future on the line.

The car arrives exactly on time, which means Sebastian is already in his office waiting for me, probably pacing, probably thinking about strategies and leverage and ways to get what he wants. The man doesn't do anything without a plan.

His office is on the forty-second floor of a building that probably has its own zip code. Floor-to-ceiling windows overlook the city like he owns it, which, knowing Sebastian, he probably does. His desk is minimalist and expensive, made of some kind of dark wood that probably has a name I don't know.

He's standing by the window when I enter, and he doesn't turn around immediately. He just lets me stand there, watching the back of his expensive suit, waiting for him to acknowledge my presence.

When he does turn, I realize he looks worse than I feel.

There are shadows under his eyes that weren't there yesterday. His jaw is tight, his hair slightly disheveled like he's been running his hands through it. He looks like a man who hasn't slept, which is either very good or very bad depending on what he's been thinking about.

"Thank you for coming," he says, and his voice is carefully neutral.

"Did I have a choice?"

"You always have a choice, Evelyn." He moves from the window to his desk, but he doesn't sit. He just leans against it, close enough that I can smell that bergamot and cedar smoke, which is either a tactical move or a sign that he's not thinking clearly. "That's what I wanted to talk to you about."

"If this is about the adoption story—"

"It's not." He holds up a hand. "I'm not here to accuse you of anything. I'm not here to demand explanations or threaten legal action or any of the things you're probably expecting."

"Then why am I here?"

"Because I spent all night doing something I'm not proud of." He runs a hand through his hair, and it's such a human gesture that it catches me off guard. "I had my security team pull your files. Everything they could find. And I found something interesting."

My stomach drops.

"Seven years ago, you disappeared for six months. No contact with your business partner, no communication with your lawyer, nothing. When you came back, you had a daughter. And according to every record I could find, there's no adoption paperwork. No surrogacy agreement. No evidence that she came from anywhere except—" He stops, and his eyes lock on mine with an intensity that makes my knees weak. "Except from you."

"Sebastian—"

"I'm not finished." He holds up a hand again. "I also found something else. Seven years ago, I was dealing with some very complicated business in Singapore. I was there for exactly six months. And during that time, you were gone. And when we both came back, everything was different."

I can't move. I can't breathe. I can't do anything except stand here and watch him piece together the truth like he's solving a particularly intricate puzzle.

"So I have a theory," he continues, and his voice is very quiet now. "And I need you to tell me if I'm right, because if I am, then everything changes. Everything."

"Don't," I whisper.

"Don't what?"

"Don't ask me. Don't make me say it. Because once it's said out loud, you can't un-say it, and I need you to understand that before you—"

"Is she mine?" he interrupts. "Is Lily mine?"

The room spins.

I can see the exact moment he realizes I'm not going to deny it. It's in the way his entire body goes rigid, the way his hands clench into fists and then deliberately relax, the way he closes his eyes like he's trying to process something that doesn't fit into any of his carefully constructed worldviews.

"Jesus Christ," he breathes. "Jesus Christ, Evelyn."

"Don't," I say again, and I'm not sure what I'm asking him not to do. Don't be angry. Don't want her. Don't take her from me. Don't make me regret the best decision I ever made.

"How could you not tell me?" When he opens his eyes, there's something raw in them that makes my chest hurt. "How could you have my daughter and not tell me?"

"Because you weren't supposed to know her," I say, and my voice sounds like it's coming from very far away. "Because I made a choice seven years ago that she would be mine and only mine. Because I couldn't risk—"

"Risk what?"

"Losing her!" The words come out like they've been clawing at my throat for seven years. "I couldn't risk you deciding you didn't want her. I couldn't risk you wanting to be involved and then disappearing. I couldn't risk her getting attached to a father who would leave. I couldn't risk any of the thousand ways this could go wrong, so I chose the one way that I could control, and that was to keep her safe and keep her mine."

Sebastian is very quiet for a long moment.

"Bring her to me," he says finally.

"No."

"Evelyn—"

"No." I move toward the door because I need to leave, I need to get out of this office and away from this man and back to my daughter. "We're done here. This conversation is over."

"If you leave this office, I will have lawyers drawing up custody paperwork before you get home," he says, and his voice is ice. "I will fight you for her, and I will win, because I have the resources and the time and the absolute certainty that she deserves to know her father. So I suggest you sit down and we talk about how we're going to handle this."

I turn back to face him, and I let him see exactly how much I hate him in this moment.

"You can try," I say quietly. "But I will burn this entire city to the ground before I let you take her from me. And unlike you, I have absolutely nothing to lose."

He steps toward me, and the space between us becomes electric.

"You're right," he says, and his voice is softer now, more dangerous. "You do have something to lose. You have her. And I'm not going to take her from you, Evelyn. I'm going to take her with you. We're going to figure out how to do this together, and if you fight me on that, I will make sure it's the most expensive and painful fight of your life."

"Is that a threat?"

"It's a promise." He's close enough now that I can feel his body heat, that I can smell the cedar and smoke and bergamot, that I can see the exact moment his anger transforms into something else entirely. "I have a daughter. And whether you like it or not, I am going to be in her life. The only question is whether you're going to make this easy or hard."

"There's nothing easy about this," I whisper.

"No," he agrees. "There isn't. But we're going to figure it out anyway. Starting with you telling me everything. Starting now."

He doesn't touch me, but he might as well have. The space between us is crackling with tension and anger and something underneath that I'm too terrified to name.

"Not here," I say finally. "Not like this."

"Then where?"

"Somewhere neutral. Somewhere we can both think clearly."

He considers this for a moment, then steps back, and I can breathe again.

"Tomorrow," he says. "We'll meet tomorrow. Just the two of us. And you're going to tell me everything, Evelyn. Every single thing. Or so help me God, I will make you regret the day you decided to keep my daughter from me."

I leave his office without responding, because there's nothing left to say.

On the drive home, I call Margot again.

"He knows," I tell her. "Everything. And he's not going to let it go."

"What are you going to do?" she asks quietly.

I look at my phone, at the photo of Lily with her magic wand and her dinosaur shirt and her father's eyes, and I realize that the answer has always been the same.

"I'm going to tell him the truth," I say. "And then I'm going to fight like hell to keep my daughter."

You might like